should people suffer beacuse of thier own actions ?

[alkal33]

im asking beacuse i wanna know if people who cause their own harm lets say a rapist gets his arms broken in the atack should get health care.

and should prison punish people other than keeping criminals togther in one place. ? beacuse that is how they seem to punish them now.

[Matt_Aranha]

@alkal33 I think it depends on the individual's intent.

In the first instance you cite I'd suggest anybody attempting that probably usually deserves whatever they suffer during the attack.

In the second instance I would say the incarcerated is supposed to be the punishment and the perpetrator ought to come to no further harm, if the law has been applied fairly.

[alkal33]

@Matt_Aranha
okay thats an interesting opinion to hold, and there is of course many factors to think of severity.